Comments on: Famous Photographs That Changed The World http://www.sandrophoto.com/2010/05/06/famous-photographs-that-changed-the-world/ Learn Photography With Sandro Dzneladze Wed, 14 Mar 2012 20:39:21 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: sandro http://www.sandrophoto.com/2010/05/06/famous-photographs-that-changed-the-world/comment-page-1/#comment-53429 sandro Mon, 19 Sep 2011 08:08:16 +0000 http://www.sandrophoto.com/?p=1189#comment-53429 This is very interesting... thanks for sharing. This is very interesting… thanks for sharing.

]]> By: Bobby http://www.sandrophoto.com/2010/05/06/famous-photographs-that-changed-the-world/comment-page-1/#comment-53218 Bobby Mon, 19 Sep 2011 01:54:42 +0000 http://www.sandrophoto.com/?p=1189#comment-53218 Hello Sandro, On the photo by Joe Rosenthal of the flag raising on Mt. Suribachi, there were, actually, 5 Marines and 1 Navy Corpsman raising the flag. During the battle for Iwo Jima, 3 of the Marines that raised the flag were killed and the 3 surviving flag raisers were flown home after the battle to help the war bond drive. Warm regards, Bobby B. Hello Sandro,

On the photo by Joe Rosenthal of the flag raising on Mt. Suribachi, there were, actually, 5 Marines and 1 Navy Corpsman raising the flag. During the battle for Iwo Jima, 3 of the Marines that raised the flag were killed and the 3 surviving flag raisers were flown home after the battle to help the war bond drive.

Warm regards,

Bobby B.

]]> By: Ross http://www.sandrophoto.com/2010/05/06/famous-photographs-that-changed-the-world/comment-page-1/#comment-47757 Ross Thu, 08 Sep 2011 22:10:34 +0000 http://www.sandrophoto.com/?p=1189#comment-47757 Thanks for choosing these images Sandro, there are a few I wasn't aware of. I am sure the photographers or their agents would have no problem with you publishing them and thus bringing the photographers to our attention. Thanks for choosing these images Sandro, there are a few I wasn’t aware of.
I am sure the photographers or their agents would have no problem with you publishing them and thus bringing the photographers to our attention.

]]> By: sandro http://www.sandrophoto.com/2010/05/06/famous-photographs-that-changed-the-world/comment-page-1/#comment-21214 sandro Mon, 14 Feb 2011 13:56:44 +0000 http://www.sandrophoto.com/?p=1189#comment-21214 I've updated the post to include the names of photographers corrected by Dave. Thanks! I’ve updated the post to include the names of photographers corrected by Dave.

Thanks!

]]> By: Dave Wyatt http://www.sandrophoto.com/2010/05/06/famous-photographs-that-changed-the-world/comment-page-1/#comment-20929 Dave Wyatt Thu, 10 Feb 2011 00:51:28 +0000 http://www.sandrophoto.com/?p=1189#comment-20929 Hi Sandro, I emailed the missing photographers (McCurry is one of the only ones intially credited in your bits of text) before I saw your second reply here. I'll cut and paste the list here: Flag Raising on Mount Suribachi is an image by Joe Rosenthal Breaker Boys is by Lewis Hine. The Lynching image is by Lawrence Beitler Not sure with the Hitler and Albert Speer image Body of Che Guevara is by Freddy Alborta The girl running away from her napalmed village is a very famous image by Nick Ut And finally the last one with missing info is the Tianamen Square image which was made by Stuart Franklin. Your fair use rationale is probably acceptable to most photographers (although certainly not all) however they would ALL expect a credit alongside their image, else what is to stop a picture researcher find the image here, not knowing who it was buy and so publishing it anyway assuming the image was free of copyright? To my mind this post has little criticism and as such the fair use arguement is pushing it but probably ok, but without full credits then not a chance. Oh, and for the most obvious omission from the edit you have chosen, Robert Capa's D-day landing images, plus many more but editing is as much about what is left out as what is left in. I thank you though for bringing a couple of the images to my attention, I'd not seen that particular Lewis Hine before and until I looked it up, didn't know Lawrence Beitler made the Lynching image. Sorry i can't help with the Hitler image, only photographer of the Nazi era in Germany I know much about is Leni Riefenstahl and I have no idea if this is one of her images. All the best Dave Hi Sandro,

I emailed the missing photographers (McCurry is one of the only ones intially credited in your bits of text) before I saw your second reply here. I’ll cut and paste the list here:

Flag Raising on Mount Suribachi is an image by Joe Rosenthal

Breaker Boys is by Lewis Hine.

The Lynching image is by Lawrence Beitler

Not sure with the Hitler and Albert Speer image

Body of Che Guevara is by Freddy Alborta

The girl running away from her napalmed village is a very famous image by Nick Ut

And finally the last one with missing info is the Tianamen Square image which was made by Stuart Franklin.

Your fair use rationale is probably acceptable to most photographers (although certainly not all) however they would ALL expect a credit alongside their image, else what is to stop a picture researcher find the image here, not knowing who it was buy and so publishing it anyway assuming the image was free of copyright? To my mind this post has little criticism and as such the fair use arguement is pushing it but probably ok, but without full credits then not a chance.

Oh, and for the most obvious omission from the edit you have chosen, Robert Capa’s D-day landing images, plus many more but editing is as much about what is left out as what is left in.

I thank you though for bringing a couple of the images to my attention, I’d not seen that particular Lewis Hine before and until I looked it up, didn’t know Lawrence Beitler made the Lynching image. Sorry i can’t help with the Hitler image, only photographer of the Nazi era in Germany I know much about is Leni Riefenstahl and I have no idea if this is one of her images.

All the best

Dave

]]>